Hulsey Lake - Nutrioso, AZ

Hulsey Lake, located in the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest near Nutrioso, AZ, is a 4-acre alpine reservoir at 8,620 feet, offering seasonal rainbow trout fishing in a peaceful, forested setting. Stocked during late spring and early summer by the Arizona Game and Fish Department, this high-elevation lake provides a quiet, shoreline-only experience.

Trout are typically caught using PowerBait, nightcrawlers, salmon eggs, and small spinners. Fly fishing is also effective, with woolly buggers and dry flies producing well during early morning or evening hatches. Due to the lake’s shallow depth, productivity peaks in June and early July before warmer temperatures reduce oxygen levels and increase weed growth.

Motorized boats and float tubes are not permitted, reinforcing the lake’s walk-in, minimalist nature. Access to prime fishing spots is easiest near the dam and inlet zones. The lake’s remoteness limits pressure and attracts campers and wildlife enthusiasts looking for solitude.

There are no developed facilities, but dispersed camping and hiking opportunities abound in the surrounding national forest. Conditions can be variable, especially in the shoulder seasons when roads may be muddy or snow-covered.

Hulsey Lake is best suited for anglers seeking a quiet, rustic setting with short-season trout action. It is a well-maintained and scenic option in Arizona’s high country.