Horton Creek Fish Report for 10-30-2026
Horton Creek Report
Horton Creek - Payson, AZ (Gila County)
by Arizona Game & Fish Department
10-30-2026
Website
Horton Creek is managed as a catch-and-release Brown Trout fishery and regulations include catch-and-release only, immediately release trout, no trout may be kept, artificial fly and lure only, single-pointed barbless hooks only and no bait.
Access to Horton Creek is granted by Horton Creek Trail 285 that starts at Upper Tonto Creek Campground and ends at Horton Springs at the base of the Mogollon RIm. The last 3/4 mile of the creek is typically dry although there may be water in this section due to monsoon weather. Brown Trout can be caught immediately when water starts to appear once you hike 3/4 miles into the perennial section of creek.
Fishing for Brown Trout is great throughout the creek, although if you want to beat the crowds it is recommended to hike 1.5 to 2 miles along the trail before starting to fish as the lower part of the creek will get more visitors.
Similar to the EVR and other area creeks, Horton has experienced large flooding events following the remnant hurricane rains. The creek will flash flood then quickly return to base Fall flows after a couple of days. As the water levels and turbidity begin to drop, this is a great opportunity to target Brown Trout. The water is just clear enough to fish yet not spook the fish. This is my favorite condition to target fish and have double digit days.
Popular fly patterns include hothead leeches (black or olive) or large prince nymph patterns. Both can be fished under an indicator focusing around cover. On clear water and warm days, small dries such as a size 14-16 elk hair caddis can be a good option.
Brown Trout spawning season is underway as fish are gearing up by beginning to make redds in the tailout of pools. Redds are spawning beds for trout and are often round/oval depressions with finer gravel and substrate. Please be mindful if wading through the stream to not disturb redds and not to target fish that are actively spawning.
Next Report >
Next Report >
More Reports
Arizona Game & Fish Department Reports
for Friday, October 30thSilver Creek AZ: Silver Creek Report
Becker Lake: Fishing has generally been very good at Becker Lake for the past month
Kaibab Lake: The lake is very low and muddy
Cataract Lake: Anglers have been catching trout on worms, lures, and flies
City Reservoir: Access to City Reservoir is closed due to poor road conditions
Dogtown Lake: Despite the recent storms, the lake level remains low
Santa Fe Lake: The lake level has come up some with the recent storms
J.D. Dam Lake: JD Dam Fishing Report
Whitehorse Lake: Whitehorse Lake Fishing Report
Upper & Lower Lake Mary: Upper and Lower Mary Report
Francis Short Pond: Anglers have been catching Rainbow Trout and Bluegill
Ashurst Lake: Ashurst Lake Report
Kinnikinick Lake: The lake has picked up a lot of water from recent storms
Oak Creek: Access to recreation areas throughout much of upper Oak Creek Canyon reopened on September 17, 2026
West Clear Creek: Fall stocking of Rainbow Trout has resumed
C.C. Cragin Reservoir: October's tropical storms have filled C.C. Cragin Reservoir
Knoll Lake: Recent storms have increased the lake levels
Colorado River - Lees Ferry: Fishing has been slow with most anglers landing 0-7 fish per day
Dead Horse Ranch State Park : The fishing has been slower at the Dead Horse Lagoons this month
Goldwater Lake: Goldwater Lake Fishing Report
Watson Lake: Channel Catfish and Largemouth Bass are being caught out of Watson
Mingus Lake: The fishing has been poor at Mingus this month due to water quality issues
Yavapai Lake: Fishing has remained slow at the Yavapai Lakes due to poor water quality
Fain Lake: Channel Catfish and Largemouth Bass are also being caught at Fain
Lake Mead: Water temperatures have fallen quite a bit since last month, and the fishing has improved
Colorado River - Willow Beach: The fishing has been good at Willow Beach
Lake Mohave: Lake Mohave Fishing Report
Colorado River - Davis Dam: Great time to go fishing
Lake Havasu: Water temperatures at Lake Havasu are in the mid 70s to low 80s throughout the day
Alamo Lake: Water temperatures at Alamo Lake fluctuate in the 70s throughout the day
Martinez Lake: Anglers have reported decent catches of Largemouth Bass
Mittry Lake: Mittry Lake Report
Parker Canyon Lake: Water is very low, but boats are still able to be launched
Rose Canyon Lake: Rose Canyon Lake Report
Riggs Flat Lake: The September and October Rainbow Trout stockings were postponed due to high pH
Roper Lake: Recent surveys have shown that Roper Lake has a high quantity of good-sized Largemouth Bass
Patagonia Lake: Patagonia Lake Report
Arivaca Lake: Bass and other warmwater fish will be making their final push to fatten up before the winter
Pena Blanca Lake: Recent fall electrofishing surveys by AZGFD have found some quality fish starting to appear in greater numbers
East Verde River: East Verde River Report
Website Hosting and Design provided by TECK.net